In 1943, Carson Shaw travels to Chicago to try out for the All-American Girls Professional Baseball League. There, she meets other women who also dream of playing pro baseball and makes connections that open up her world. Rockford local Max Chapman also comes to the tryouts but is turned away. With the support of her best friend Clance, she must forge a new path to pursue her dream.
Their game. Their rules.
Created by: Abbi Jacobson, Will Graham
Abbi Jacobson
Carson Shaw
1
Worst Performance
Chanté Adams
Max Chapman
D'Arcy Carden
Greta Gill
1
Best Performance
Gbemisola Ikumelo
Clance Morgan
1
Scene Stealer
Kelly McCormack
Jess McCready
Roberta Colindrez
Lupe GarcĂa
Melanie Field
Jo De Luca
Priscilla Delgado
Esti González
Joe Fishel
Umpire
Kate Berlant
Shirley Cohen
Molly Ephraim
Maybelle Fox
Dale Dickey
Baverly
Jon Osbeck
Bob the Announcer
Kendall Johnson
Gary
Lil Frex
Ana
Rae Gray
Terri
Alex DĂ©sert
Edgar
Saidah Arrika Ekulona
Toni
Michael Buonomo
Stu
Don Fanelli
Alan Baker
Aaron Jennings
Guy
Patrick J. Adams
Charlie
Nat Faxon
Marshall
Jerren Jackson
Big C
Philip Winters
Arnie Vance
Patrice Covington
Gracie
Lea Robinson
Bertie
Treisa Gary
Georgia
Diane Sellers
Lynn
Nick Offerman
Dove Porter
John L Criswell Jr.
Howie
RJ Lewis
Maurice
Bryant Bentley
Jon
Latrisha Talley
Cheryl
Andia Winslow
Esther
Kevin Dunn
Morris Baker
Nancy Lenehan
Vivienne
Marinda Anderson
Leah
Stan Sellers
Greg the Announcer
Marquise Vilson
Red Wright
Jeff Hochendoner
Umpire
Kate Cochran
Emma
Rosie O'Donnell
Vi
Stephanie Erb
Edie
Clyde Harper
Jay
Juliene Joyner
Flo
Aria Moody
Willa
Ava Duvall
Fangirl Twin #1
Kora Duvall
Fangirl Twin #2
Schwa de Vivre
Drag Queen
B+
A
B
C
D
F
Acting Quality
Character Depth
World Building
Originality
Consistency
Re-Watchability
Reviews
I struggled with this one. I love the obvious effort to be more inclusive, both in terms of race and sexual identity. But Max's story diverted too far from the league to make it feel cohesive, and Abbi struggled to carry the lead role. Overall I just found it slow paced and a bit boring, as much as I wanted to like it. The exception is the finale, which was excellent and had me in tears and chills multiple times.
Grade: C+ / HeathersCorner / Nov 17, 2022